Does your partner’s concern for your safety make you feel secure or secretly a bit suffocated? It can be hard to tell the difference between healthy protectiveness and toxic control. In relationships, as in life, things are not always black and white. Good intentions can be demonstrated badly, and it is sometimes difficult to know where the line is between protective behavior and controlling behavior. Let’s unpack these tricky feelings and figure out where YOUR relationship falls on the spectrum.
Dave’s dilemma: Protecting vs. controlling
Real life isn’t black and white. Dave’s story shows how trauma can lead to well-intentioned actions that still have harmful consequences. Here’s a breakdown of Dave’s situation:
- The Problem: Dave was restricting his girlfriend’s freedom to go out with friends out of fear, which IS controlling, even if he doesn’t see it that way.
- The Nuance: Dave’s self-awareness of his controllingness is positive, but that doesn’t negate the impact on his partner.
- Why It’s Confusing: We crave easy labels. “Protective” feels good, “controlling” feels bad, but sometimes BOTH are true.
Finding the Line: Here’s how to break this down:
- Dave’s Responsibility: He needs to address his trauma so he can be protective WITHOUT controlling. Therapy is key.
- Girlfriend’s Needs: She has a right to independence. Setting gentle boundaries while acknowledging his fears is a good start.
- Not an Excuse: Until Dave heals, a healthy relationship may be difficult. This doesn’t make him a villain, just not partner-ready.
Controlling behavior vs. protectiveness
It’s easy to confuse controlling behavior and genuine protectiveness, but the intent matters. Let’s look at common situations:
Behaviors Regarding Your Friend/Family Relationships:
- Controlling: Isolating you by criticizing your loved ones, aiming to reduce their influence. (“I don’t like Andrea…”)
- Protective: Expresses concern about a specific negative dynamic in your friendship, focusing on how it impacts YOU. (“Andrea seems kind of dismissive towards you…”)
Behaviors Around Feedback from Partner:
- Controlling: Constant criticism about multiple aspects of your life, with the goal of changing who you are to fit their preferences. (“Wouldn’t a more modest outfit look better?”)
- Protective: Supportive offers of help if YOU decide to change something, respecting your choices. (“Worried about your health with smoking, I’m here if you ever want to quit…”)
Behaviors Regarding Your Wants/Needs:
- Controlling: Disregards your needs, pressuring you to conform to what THEY want, even in small matters. For example, you’re a vegetarian, but your partner insists on cooking meat-heavy dishes every night. They dismiss your requests for plant-based meals or make you feel guilty about your choices.
- Protective: Prioritizes your needs, seeking to understand them and offering compromises that ensure you both feel comfortable. For example, they offer to make a plant-based meal for you once a week as a compromise because they know that’s what you want.
Behaviors Around Rules and Standards:
- Controlling: Double standards apply – what’s okay for them is forbidden for you. This creates an uneven power dynamic. For example, your partner has no problem going out with their friends on a regular basis but gets upset or suspicious when you want a night out with yours.
- Protective: Rules are either mutually agreed upon or simply absent, as there’s no need to control the other person.
Behaviors Around Spending Time Apart:
- Controlling: Feels threatened by your need for individuality and space. They may intrude on your social plans or express insecurity when you’re having fun without them.
- Protective: Trusts you and respects your right to have your own life. They support your friendships, hobbies, and activities, even if they don’t participate.
Key Takeaway: Control is about changing you. Protection is about respecting who you are while offering support and concern for your well-being.
Prenups: A practical tool
If one partner worries about the other’s spending habits, risky investments, or potential debt, a prenuptial agreement can offer some protection. It can set clear rules around:
- Separate vs. Shared Assets: Defining what’s owned individually vs. what’s shared in the marriage and may be divided in a divorce
- Debt Protection: Limiting one spouse’s liability for the other’s debts, whether taken on before or during marriage.
- Alimony (Spousal Support): Waiving it completely or setting limits or terms for payments if the marriage ends.
However, prenups cannot fix a foundational relationship issue, such as controlling behaviors. If you suspect your partner is more controlling than protective, you may want to seek out help.
Takeaway: A prenup is a great, practical tool to set boundaries and protect your future self. Open communication about money and values is vital. If deep-seated worries persist, counseling to address the root causes may be a good option.
Understanding the difference and finding your power
Navigating the blurry line between care and control in a relationship can be incredibly confusing. Remember, you deserve to feel both safe AND free within your partnership. Here’s how to move forward:
- Self-Reflection: Honestly examine the examples discussed. Are similar patterns present in your own life? This awareness is crucial.
- Open Communication: If concerns linger, a loving but direct conversation with your partner is essential. Share your feelings and needs without accusations.
- Seek Support: If these conversations feel too difficult alone, couples therapy can provide expert guidance and a safe space. You don’t have to figure this out alone.
- Trust Your Gut: If something consistently doesn’t feel right, even if you can’t perfectly explain why, those feelings matter. You’re entitled to set boundaries that honor your well-being.
And don’t forget to co-create your future & protect your ass(ets) with a prenup today!
Julia Rodgers is HelloPrenup’s CEO and Co-Founder. She is a Massachusetts family law attorney and true believer in the value of prenuptial agreements. HelloPrenup was created with the goal of automating the prenup process, making it more collaborative, time efficient and cost effective. Julia believes that a healthy marriage is one in which couples can openly communicate about finances and life goals. You can read more about us here Questions? Reach out to Julia directly at [email protected].
0 Comments