Couples therapy is often seen as a last resort for couples. It’s what friends recommend after they’ve given you all the advice they can give, or feel over their heads about how to help you. It’s what partners throw out so they can say they gave it their all before calling quits. Or, for some future-thinking couples, it’s something that is done like preventative health services—to provide a strong foundation before and during the relationship or marriage.
But what actually happens in couples therapy, and can it make things worse? The answer to that, like most of therapy, is not straightforward. Couples therapy can absolutely help—but it can also feel like it’s making things worse, at least at first. Sometimes it even leads couples to separate. And here’s the twist: that doesn’t necessarily mean therapy failed.
Let’s explore more the impacts of couples’ therapy, why “getting worse” may actually be a part of the healing, when therapy isn’t the right fit, and how to recognize when ending a relationship is the healthiest outcome.
Therapy isn’t passive
A relationship is a system, with rules and rhythms that partners follow, whether they’re aware of them or not. Couples therapy actively disrupts that system and its patterns. That’s the whole point of therapy—to identify what’s not working and to make changes.
Let’s use Maria and Daniel as an example. For years, Maria went quiet whenever conflict arose. Daniel learned to stop bringing things up because he didn’t want to be met with silence. When they started therapy, Maria finally said out loud, “I’ve been resentful for years about doing most of the childcare.” Daniel felt blindsided and immediately defensive; he had tried for so long to talk about this, but had felt shut down at every attempt. Therapy didn’t create the conflict; it exposed it openly.
Therapy isn’t just a safe space to ‘talk’—it’s an intervention. Whether the focus is on identifying patterns, processing emotions, or making active behavioral changes, therapy is designed to move clients forward in a meaningful way. And change doesn’t always feel good right away (think of it like eating your vegetables as a kid—uncomfortable at first, but ultimately nourishing)
Why couples therapy can feel worse at first
Life moves fast, and over the months and years, couples often learn—consciously or unconsciously—to live with unspoken grievances. Some are small, like forgetting to wipe down the sink, while others, like not standing up for a partner with their parents, can carry a much bigger impact.
Couples therapy is designed to bring these unspoken issues to the surface, and depending on how long they’ve been buried, they can carry a little or a lot of emotional weight. Therapy is the safest place for them to emerge—guided by a neutral expert with both partners present for the same purpose—but that doesn’t erase the tension, and that’s natural. And because therapy is only one hour out of 168 in a week, what arises in session often stirs up feelings that linger between sessions.
Here are some of the other common reasons therapy feels painful at first:
Defenses get stripped away
Everyone has strategies to protect themselves, or what we call defenses. Behaviors such as avoidance, sarcasm, and even overfunctioning are explored and challenged in therapy. During this process, it’s normal to feel exposed, blamed, or overanalyzed.
Progress isn’t linear
In therapy, the overall progress over time is often upward, but from one week to the next, it can feel like a rollercoaster. One breakthrough session can be followed by three painful ones. So, with that experience, no wonder couples wonder, “Is this making things worse for us?!”
Different readiness levels
Just because both partners have agreed to attend therapy together, it doesn’t mean they’re both ready to engage at the same level. One partner may be prepared to make active changes, while the other is still trying to figure out the structure of the session. Readiness levels can also change throughout therapy depending on what is discovered and what may need to be done.
Building new muscles
Each person may have a different level of exposure and experience with emotional discussions, vulnerability, and processing. For those who have not had as much practice in these areas, it’s a new skill to learn and build. During that time, it can feel hard, just like learning any new skill. Only with time and practice does it become easier to engage in something that may feel simple, like answering, “How does that make you feel?”
The critical thing to remember is that this initial turbulence isn’t necessarily a sign that therapy is failing—it’s often the messy beginning of meaningful change.
When therapy truly makes things worse
At the end of the day, therapy is a tool and intervention, and when not applied properly or for the correct situation, it can cause harm. Let’s explore common ways so you can make an informed decision.
Unwilling participation.
If one partner comes to therapy under duress (“come or else”), sessions are likely to feel manipulative rather than collaborative. That dynamic creates a significant barrier to progress, making it much harder for the reluctant partner to feel safe enough to share their true thoughts or feelings.
Poor therapeutic fit.
Not every therapist is trained in couples work. Without grounding in evidence-based approaches and experience working with couples, a therapist may unintentionally side with one partner, minimize key issues, or overlook destructive patterns. Just as crucial, the therapist must build a strong therapeutic alliance with the couple as a unit—not just with one individual.
In unsafe situations.
When there is active abuse, untreated addiction, or threats to safety, couples therapy is often not the first step. In these cases, it’s usually recommended that each partner seek individual support first—such as substance use treatment or anger management. Otherwise, joint sessions can unintentionally empower the abusive partner or retraumatize the vulnerable one.
When couples stop too soon.
Therapy often begins with uncovering hidden hurts before moving into the action (or repair) stage. If couples quit after those first painful sessions, they’re left with raw tension but no tools to heal. Stopping early can make things feel worse, not better.
Knowing these risks doesn’t mean avoiding therapy altogether—it means entering with eyes open, choosing the proper support, and committing long enough to reach the stage where healing can actually take place.
When “worse” is actually progress
When couples begin to voice long-hidden truths, the atmosphere often feels stormier. Yet over time, that very vulnerability becomes the foundation for rebuilding intimacy. What feels like conflict can actually signal movement—partners are finally addressing what has been avoided.
Therapy is much like physical rehab: at first, stretching scar tissue hurts. That pain doesn’t mean the process is harmful—it means the body is relearning how to move and strengthening old muscles. Couples therapy works the same way. Partners are learning to drop their crutches, lean into discomfort, and practice moving together again.
This is why those “worse” moments often turn out to be progress in disguise. The raised voices, the tears, even the temporary increase in tension—all of it means something important is surfacing and being worked through rather than silently festering. Many couples, looking back, describe their hardest sessions as the very ones that became powerful turning points.
Signs therapy is helping—even if it’s hard
When you’re in the middle of tough sessions, it can be hard to tell whether the work is moving you forward or pulling you apart. One way to gauge progress is to look for certain shifts that signal therapy is working, even if it doesn’t feel easy in the moment:
- Fights may still happen, but they’re more contained and productive.
- Each partner feels more understood, even if they don’t agree with each other.
- Both partners report increased clarity about what they want.
- Emotional honesty grows, even if it’s messy.
If you notice even a few of these changes, it’s a sign that therapy is doing its job—helping you build a different way of relating, step by step.
The paradox: Success can mean breaking up
Sometimes, the most successful couples therapy ends with separation. That doesn’t mean the therapist failed or the couple wasted their time; it simply means that through the work, the couple has clarified that the healthiest path forward is to be apart.
There may be several situations when this occurs. For some couples, it’s when they come to realize that their core values are fundamentally misaligned—for example, one wants children while the other (who thought they did) actually realizes they don’t. It can also happen when trust has been deeply shattered, and despite attempts at repair, there’s no genuine desire to rebuild. In other cases, resentment has hardened over time to the point where tenderness no longer returns, leaving the relationship unable to regain its emotional footing.
Good therapy doesn’t force reconciliation; it supports clarity. For some couples, clarity means choosing to part ways with care and respect.
How to separate in a healthy way
If therapy clarifies that ending the relationship is the right path, the process can still be deeply beneficial, logistically and emotionally. Here’s how:
Use therapy as a container.
A therapist can help create a safe and constructive space to keep discussions focused and less reactive, so partners aren’t stuck cycling through the same arguments. This helps reduce the risk of any re-traumatization and unnecessary harm, and allows each partner to feel heard. Over time, therapy can also facilitate difficult conversations, such as division of assets, parenting transitions, or closure, in a way that feels respectful and stabilizing.
Closure.
Even when parting, couples can use therapy to honor the good years, the lessons learned, and the fact that the relationship mattered. This helps prevent rewriting history as “all bad” and seeing it for all its highs and lows.
Focus on co-parenting (if relevant).
For couples with children, therapy can transition into structured co-parenting work, emphasizing stability for kids through this time and after.
Set boundaries early.
Healthy separation often requires agreements around communication, finances, and social media. Therapy can provide a neutral ground to establish those so that both partners feel like they’re on the same page.
Protect individual healing.
During this time, individual therapy can be paired with the couple work, which can help ensure that both partners can grieve, reflect, and move forward for themselves.
While separation is never easy, approaching it with support, structure, and intention can transform the process from one of pure loss into an opportunity for dignity, clarity, and a healthier path forward for both partners.
The bottom line on whether couples therapy makes things worse or not
So, can couples therapy make things worse? In the short term—yes. It can stir up conflict, expose resentment, and leave you wondering if you made a mistake pursuing therapy. And, in unsafe or poorly handled situations, it can genuinely cause harm.
But more often, the “worse” is actually the dust kicked up by long-avoided truths and discussions. And when couples stay with the process, that storm can clear the air, providing clarity for the relationship and each partner.
And remember, sometimes the healthiest outcome isn’t reconciliation. It’s the clarity to end a relationship with compassion and integrity. Therapy, at its best, doesn’t dictate that outcome—it equips you to make it consciously, whether together or apart.
Approach couples therapy with curiosity, and it’s far more likely to help you and your partner begin moving forward again with greater honesty and freedom.
Dr. Vivian Oberling is a licensed clinical psychologist with degrees from UCLA, Harvard, and Stanford. In her private telehealth practice, she works with adults navigating anxiety, identity shifts, and relationship dynamics—whether they’re dating, partnered, or parenting. She also provides executive coaching and behavioral health advisory support to tech startups and legal tools reshaping how we think about love, marriage, and psychological safety. Dr. Oberling combines 10+ years of clinical expertise with modern, real-world insight to help people move through uncertainty with clarity and connection.
0 Comments